Jump to content

The No Nonsense Top 50


Omaha Vol

Recommended Posts

Some shuffling around due to some close calls, but relatively the same. 

1. Santa Ana(CA) Mater Dei

2. Bellflower(CA) St. John Bosco

3. Duncanville(TX)

4. Baltimore(MD) St. Frances

5. Ft. Lauderdale(FL) Aquinas

6. Bradenton(FL) IMG

7. Valdosta(GA) Lowndes

8. Lakeland(FL)

9. Honolulu(HI) St. Louis

10. Concord(CA) De LaSalle

11. Katy(TX)

12. Houston(TX) N. Shore

13. Philadelphia(PA) St. Joseph's

14. Washington(DC) St. John's

15. Draper(UT) Corner Canyon

16. Las Vegas(NV) Gorman

17. Longview(TX)

18. Chandler(AZ)

19. Mentor(OH)

20. Powder Springs(GA) McEachern

21. Lakewood(OH) St. Edward

22. Southlake(TX) Carroll

23. Bryant(AR)

24. Norman Park(GA) Colquitt Co.

25. Miami(FL) Northwestern

26. Hyattsville(MD) DeMatha

27. Olney(MD) Good Counsel

28. Corona(CA) Centennial

29. Allen(TX)

30. Owasso(OK)

31. Marietta(GA)

32. Baton Rouge(LA) Catholic

33. Mission Viejo(CA)

34. Charlotte(NC) Mallard Creek

35. Irmo(SC) Dutch Fork

36. Louisville(KY) Male

37. Denton(TX) Guyer

38. Metairie(LA) Rummel

39. River Ridge(LA) Curtis

40. Roebuck(SC) Dorman

41. Suwanee(GA) N. Gwinnett

42. Seffner(FL) Armwood

43. Murfreesboro(TN) Oakland

44. Duncan(SC) Byrnes

45. W. Monroe(LA)

46. Montvale(NJ) St. Joseph

47. St. Louis(MO) DeSmet

48. Frisco(TX) Lone Star

49. Cincinnati(OH) Elder

50. Aledo(TX)

Just missed:

Akron(OH) Hoban

Cedar Hill(TX)

Anaheim(CA) Servite

Harbor City(CA) Narbonne

Plantation(FL) American Heritage

Massillon(OH) Washington

Maryville(TN)

Frankfort(IL) Lincoln-Way East

Rockingham(NC) Richmond

Bixby(OK)

 

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, Omaha Vol said:

Some shuffling around due to some close calls, but relatively the same. 

1. Santa Ana(CA) Mater Dei

2. Bellflower(CA) St. John Bosco

3. Duncanville(TX)

4. Baltimore(MD) St. Frances

5. Ft. Lauderdale(FL) Aquinas

6. Bradenton(FL) IMG

7. Valdosta(GA) Lowndes

8. Lakeland(FL)

9. Honolulu(HI) St. Louis

10. Concord(CA) De LaSalle

11. Katy(TX)

12. Houston(TX) N. Shore

13. Philadelphia(PA) St. Joseph's

14. Washington(DC) St. John's

15. Draper(UT) Corner Canyon

16. Las Vegas(NV) Gorman

17. Longview(TX)

18. Chandler(AZ)

19. Mentor(OH)

20. Powder Springs(GA) McEachern

21. Lakewood(OH) St. Edward

22. Southlake(TX) Carroll

23. Bryant(AR)

24. Norman Park(GA) Colquitt Co.

25. Miami(FL) Northwestern

26. Hyattsville(MD) DeMatha

27. Olney(MD) Good Counsel

28. Corona(CA) Centennial

29. Allen(TX)

30. Owasso(OK)

31. Marietta(GA)

32. Baton Rouge(LA) Catholic

33. Mission Viejo(CA)

34. Charlotte(NC) Mallard Creek

35. Irmo(SC) Dutch Fork

36. Louisville(KY) Male

37. Denton(TX) Guyer

38. Metairie(LA) Rummel

39. River Ridge(LA) Curtis

40. Roebuck(SC) Dorman

41. Suwanee(GA) N. Gwinnett

42. Seffner(FL) Armwood

43. Murfreesboro(TN) Oakland

44. Duncan(SC) Byrnes

45. W. Monroe(LA)

46. Montvale(NJ) St. Joseph

47. St. Louis(MO) DeSmet

48. Frisco(TX) Lone Star

49. Cincinnati(OH) Elder

50. Aledo(TX)

Just missed:

Akron(OH) Hoban

Cedar Hill(TX)

Anaheim(CA) Servite

Harbor City(CA) Narbonne

Plantation(FL) American Heritage

Massillon(OH) Washington

Maryville(TN)

Frankfort(IL) Lincoln-Way East

Rockingham(NC) Richmond

Bixby(OK)

 

Hopes for an improved product.......dashed.  Sad.

  • Like 1
  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Omaha Vol said:

What made you think it would drastically change? Or did you think I was going to move Servite up and right behind MV in the 30’s? Lol

You considered the 1 point loss to SJB a fluke,  Then the 3 point loss to MV showed that the 1 point loss to SJB was not a fluke.

Still Servite can't crack your top 50.

Which teams in your 35-50 ranking would have a better record than Servite, had they played the same schedule?

  • Thanks 1
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Sammyswordsman said:

You considered the 1 point loss to SJB a fluke,  Then the 3 point loss to MV showed that the 1 point loss to SJB was not a fluke.

Still Servite can't crack your top 50.

Which teams in your 35-50 ranking would have a better record than Servite, had they played the same schedule?

They might not necessarily have a better record. We are talking about the difference between 20 teams out of 15K. That’s such a small difference. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

20 minutes ago, Omaha Vol said:

They might not necessarily have a better record. We are talking about the difference between 20 teams out of 15K. That’s such a small difference. 

Then why not give Servite the benefit of the doubt rather than the other 15 teams?  At lease Servite is vetted against 4 Top 35 teams, and played your #2 and #33 within a combined 4 points.

What is your response other than just to spite me.

  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, ECHS05 said:

Lowndes > STA & IMG.

Lowndes & IMG have a common opponent... Guess who dominated that opponent more thoroughly...

Can't argue with that at the moment. Can't prove it, either, of course. I think STA would be favored over MNW, but would be quite surprised to win by something like 48-21. IMO, Lowndes has a strong claim to be #2 in the country.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 minutes ago, Sammyswordsman said:

Then why not give Servite the benefit of the doubt rather than the other 15 teams?  At lease Servite is vetted against 4 Top 35 teams, and played your #2 and #33 within a combined 4 points.

What is your response other than just to spite me.

Why not let a California homer like yourself be the one to give Servite the benefit of the doubt?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, badrouter said:

Can't argue with that at the moment. Can't prove it, either, of course. I think STA would be favored over MNW, but would be quite surprised to win by something like 48-21. IMO, Lowndes has a strong claim to be #2 in the country.

That would mean I have to realistically believe they could actually defeat SFA or SJB head to head but unless Lowndes goes to Geico bowl they haven't proven they should finish in top 5 for same reason Lakeland likely needs to win out just to finish top 5 in SOME polls

 

They have a good win over MNW, they don't have a elite resume that would justify that high of a ranking 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, badrouter said:

Can't argue with that at the moment. Can't prove it, either, of course. I think STA would be favored over MNW, but would be quite surprised to win by something like 48-21. IMO, Lowndes has a strong claim to be #2 in the country.

That would mean I have to realistically believe they could actually defeat SFA or SJB head to head but unless Lowndes goes to Geico bowl they haven't proven they should finish in top 5 for same reason Lakeland likely needs to win out just to finish top 5 in SOME polls

 

They have a good win over MNW, they don't have a elite resume that would justify that high of a ranking 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, Columbiafan said:

That would mean I have to realistically believe they could actually defeat SFA or SJB head to head but unless Lowndes goes to Geico bowl they haven't proven they should finish in top 5 for same reason Lakeland likely needs to win out just to finish top 5 in SOME polls

 

They have a good win over MNW, they don't have a elite resume that would justify that high of a ranking 

They also have good wins over Colquitt and Valdosta.

What is the evidence suggesting they couldn't defeat SFA or SJB?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, Columbiafan said:

Have they defeated anyone at the same level of SFA or SJB?

 

Colquitt, Valdosta, and MNW are teams ranging from 26-100 nationally 

 

 

None are top 5 teams like SFA or SJB

They beat them all by double digits or worse. And, give us rundown of the best teams SFA and SJB have beaten. How do those teams compare to the teams Lowndes has beaten? 

 I still see no evidence that they couldn't beat those teams. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, badrouter said:

They beat them all by double digits or worse. And, give us rundown of the best teams SFA and SJB have beaten.

So, I still see no evidence that they couldn't beat those teams. 

I'll leave SJB to the CA posters 

 

 

SFA defeated Miami Central AT TRAZ POWELL 49-13

 

Defeated SJR IN NJ 28-0

 

Defeated Venice ON ROAD 49-7 

 

 

And defeated IMG 35-7 

 

 

 

3/4 top wins came on the road and convincingly

 

 

 

 

Lowndes top 3 wins with MNW, Valdosta and Colquitt all came AT LOWNDES 

 

With margin of victories coming between 11 points (Colquitt) and 27 points (MNW) and 24-0 over Valdosta

  • Thanks 1
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.


×
×
  • Create New...